27-year-old Nathan Horton 26-year-old Johnathan Hudson, both of Westfield, turned themselves into Chautauqua County Sheriff's deputies on Monday.
Deputies say they tried to cut off catalytic converters from two cars at the lot on January 7. Investigators determined Horton and Hudson were responsible and warrants were issued for their arrests.
They are both charged with criminal mischief and criminal liability for the conduct of another. Hudson is in jail. Horton was released to family members.